Advertisement

labour court

This week Ivan Israelstam addresses the danger of an approach used by some employers, who have not effectively managed performance and behaviour. To remove "troublesome" employees - who should have been disciplined or performance managed - the employer goes to great lengths to manipulate positions, and to create a redeployment pool, which effectively amounts to a redundancy pool. Ivan demonstrates how the Labour Appeal Court has the power to uncover alternative agenda, and the consequences of such poor management performance. 

What is a "transfer as a going concern" and what are the implications for employees who are part of the transfer? This week Ivan Israelstam explains how the courts have developed the answer to these very complex questions over a period of time. 

Ivan Israelstam

Many employers will be able to relate to the situation of being infurirated by employee behaviour. However, as Ivan Israelstam explains this week, it is very dangerous for an employer to react emotionally and overstate the allegation of misconduct - by alleging dereliction of duty. This term has a very specific legal meaning and therefore at the CCMA the employer will have the responsibility for proving that the misconduct was a deliberate and intentional action by the employee.

Before embarking upon large scale retrechments, employers need to have a very clear understanding of what labour law requires. This week Ivan Israelstam explains the definition of large scale retrenchment and describes how the Labour Court has decided on retrenchment procedures. He concludes that everything is not clear and advises employers to seek legal assistance before embarking on large scale retrenchments.

Why do some employers regards employees as an expense rather than an investment to nurture and retain? This week Ivan Israelstam explores the costs to an employer of non-compliance with labour laws, and gives constructive advice to employers on how to adopt a balanced approach.

The Code of Good Practice on Dismissal (Schedule 8 of the Labour Relations Act) provides the guidelines for employers to follow in disciplinary proceedings. This code does not specifically require "cross-examination" but does provide that the employee must be aware of the allegations against them, to understand them, and be given a chance to state their side of the story - or defence - in response to the allegations.This week Ivan Israelstam explains the meaning of "cross-examination" and provides advice on how employers should proceed.

The South African Constitution provides employees with the right to fair labour practices. Prior to a dismissal decision an employee should be made aware of the allegations against him/her and given chance to be heard on the matter.

When does South African labour law apply? This week Ivan gives us a number of examples where foreign firms thought - incorrectly - that they could do as they please with their employees. No - not so. Ivan demonstrates through a number of cases where these employers made some very serious - and extremely expensive - mistakes. Our courts found that they did have jurisdiction and the defaulting employers paid the employees' costs - in addition to all the other costs.

When employers include disciplinary policy, procedures and codes in employment contracts, it is especially important that the employer follow their own documented procedures. Failure to follow their own procedures will call into question the status of the dismissal of employees. In this case Ivan Israelstam details how the Labour Court judge analysed the failures of both the employer, and the CCMA arbitrator, who supported the dismissal.

In the past, employers has consistently refused to allow lawyers to be present at internal disciplinary hearings. However, the ground has shifted slightly and employers would be well advised to consider the individual circumstances and individual disciplinary matter that is being heard. This week Ivan Israelstam explains how the ground has shifted.

Pages

Advertisement

Subscribe to labour court